For many years, 1000’s of individuals got here to Trinidad, Colorado, to have gender affirmation surgical procedure achieved by Dr. Stanley Biber. This excerpt from Going To Trinidad tells his—and one among his affected person’s—poignant tales.
•
On December 12, 1990, a legislation workplace secretary and part-time English graduate scholar in Rancho Cucamonga, California, sat down to write down a letter that had been almost 4 a long time within the making. Her identify was Claudine Toni Griggs.
The diminutive Griggs had lived as a girl for 16 years, for the reason that summer season of 1974, although she’d been born and spent the primary 21 years of her life as Claude Anthony Griggs. So full had been her outward transformation from male to feminine that few of her pals {and professional} colleagues knew. At five-feet-five and 120 kilos, she says, “All I needed to do to look sexually ambiguous was shave what little facial hair I had.” Plus, for 17 years she’d been taking hormone remedies that eased her even additional towards the feminine finish of the gender spectrum. Her transition had stalled wanting the subsequent logical step, although: surgical procedure that will rework her male genitalia into that of a feminine. However by early December 1990, Griggs had made peace with that call.
Extra from our April 2021 Challenge
Throughout a routine appointment along with her endocrinologist lower than two weeks earlier, although, her physician had requested a direct, provocative query: “When are you planning to have surgical procedure?”
“By no means,” she replied. “I’ve realized to stay with out it.”
The physician pressed. “Why don’t you need to have the surgical procedure?”
When she’d explored the chance within the Nineteen Seventies, Griggs informed him, she’d discovered the attitudes of the docs she approached off-putting. Her half-dozen encounters with varied surgeons, medical facilities, psychiatrists, and others left her feeling they have been “lower than educated, generally lower than competent and fewer than moral.” In her journal, she later allowed herself to recollect these tough encounters: “If you happen to do the whole lot we let you know, once we let you know, and persuade us you can be profitable as a girl (their definition of ‘success’), then we’ll contemplate, after retaining you underneath our scrutiny for a number of years, whether or not to authorize closing intercourse reassignment; and keep in mind, we hardly ever approve surgical procedure (no different was ever talked about). On one event, I met with a barely extra harmful perspective: ‘If you happen to’ve acquired the cash, I’ll do surgical procedure—instantly.’ ”
As soon as, in 1977, she’d gotten so far as scheduling the operation—solely to search out out the chosen surgeon had misplaced his medical license simply weeks earlier than he was set to do her surgical procedure. “I used to be informed by one other doctor that ‘he had butchered a few individuals,’ ” Griggs later recalled. “To today, I don’t consider I’ve utterly recovered from the expertise.”
The endocrinologist shook his head, assuring Griggs that issues had improved. Nonetheless anxious about revisiting the concept, she couldn’t escape that thought as she left his workplace that morning. A “acquainted and horrible emotional storm” started to swell, and she or he discovered herself crying in the course of the drive dwelling.
5 days later, throughout a telephone name, she requested the physician to assist her establish and find one of many specialists he’d advised may assist. The physician referred her to a nun in close by Orange County, who he stated had expertise in connecting transgender individuals with a health care provider who might do the kind of surgical procedure she was searching for. Though they by no means met in particular person, Griggs right now believes the nun was herself a transgender lady and was ready to make a referral primarily based on her personal expertise.
Griggs made the decision. After a telephone session wherein Griggs answered questions on how lengthy she’d lived as a girl, whether or not she was taking hormones, and if she was in counseling, the nun merely stated: “Most sufferers go to Dr. Biber.”
Who?
Griggs was given the contact info for an workplace in a spot that sounded as if it have been the center of nowhere, a small city 200 miles south of Denver close to the New Mexico border that the New York Instances a few years later would describe as “the sex-change capital of the world”: Trinidad, Colorado. “I had by no means heard of Dr. Biber or Trinidad till I used to be referred to his workplace, and I actually didn’t need to journey to this point for the surgical procedure,” Griggs says right now. “However I needed the process badly sufficient to do it nonetheless.”
Griggs’ inconceivable adviser, the Orange County nun, was appropriate. Since 1969, Dr. Stanley H. Biber had been specializing in one thing that few surgeons dared try, and he had been doing so in maybe the unlikeliest place on the planet.
Trinidad, a small city alongside the southern Colorado–northern New Mexico border, as soon as was a coal mining and ranching outpost that right now is dwelling to solely about 8,000 individuals. Whereas it has a colourful historical past and maintains a captivating downtown, Trinidad has at all times been the type of place the place road-numbed motorists touring Interstate 25 between Denver and Santa Fe exit simply lengthy sufficient to high off their gasoline tanks, refill their go-cups, and use the toilet.
Trinidad’s solely hospital, which serves a inhabitants that’s greater than 50 % Latino, nonetheless has solely 25 beds. Biber had carried out the primary of greater than 6,000 gender affirmation surgical procedures there in 1969 throughout a profession that will final till he was in his 80s.
The confident physician—himself a bantam at five-five, however who as soon as was a bodybuilder—had honed his surgical expertise as chief surgeon of a Cell Military Surgical Hospital, or MASH unit, in the course of the Korean Warfare and spent the early years of his profession centered on appendectomies, tonsillectomies, and C-section births. However at some point a social employee and private good friend requested a query on the finish of an in any other case routine appointment: Would Biber contemplate performing a fragile surgical procedure?
“In fact I can do your surgical procedure. What would you like achieved?”
His customer defined that she was a transgender lady.
“What’s that?” he replied.
On the time, few U.S. surgeons had ever carried out a gender affirmation surgical procedure. About 18 years had handed for the reason that phrase “intercourse change” first entered the American lexicon, when an American soldier who was assigned male at start traveled to Denmark to develop into Christine Jorgensen. However Biber by no means lacked for confidence and commenced researching the concept. He consulted a health care provider in New York who’d carried out the male-to-female surgical procedure, obtained some hand-drawn diagrams from Johns Hopkins College, and with out informing his bosses at then-Catholic Mt. San Rafael Hospital, agreed to provide the experimental operation a strive.
It was the start of a medical specialty he by no means might have imagined. As he started to refine his strategies, phrase acquired round. By the point Griggs first heard Biber’s identify in late 1990, the phrase “going to Trinidad” had develop into a well-recognized euphemism for present process that kind of surgical procedure amongst transgender women and men world wide.
Griggs thanked the nun for the knowledge, hung up the telephone, and stared for a number of minutes at her notepad. Don’t get too excited, she remembers considering. Don’t get your hopes up till you may have really heard from this particular person. She knew the screening course of to qualify for the surgical procedure could possibly be rigorous, primarily based on tips really useful for treating these with gender dysphoria. She additionally knew that solely a handful of docs on this planet have been able to doing what she needed achieved. It was an extended shot, and she or he was afraid to think about. For individuals like her, she later wrote, “the space from faintish optimism to the brink of suicide could be very quick.”
Six days later, in accordance with her journal, Griggs sat down at her keyboard and commenced to kind. “Expensive Dr. Biber,” she started, making an attempt to sound businesslike and restrained. “I used to be referred to your workplace by Dr. Herbert Roberts, M.D. [a pseudonym Griggs created for UCLA’s Dr. Gerald Leve to mask his identity, among others, in her published journal]. Dr. Roberts signifies that a lot of his transsexual sufferers have had surgical procedure by your workplace. I’ve been underneath Dr. Roberts’ look after 17 years. Would you please ship me info concerning your necessities for my having surgical procedure by your workplace? If you happen to want extra info or have any questions, don’t hesitate to name. Thanks. I’m trying ahead to listening to from you. Very really yours, Claudine Griggs.”
She recorded her emotions about sending the letter in her journal. Reflecting on the letter’s tone, she wrote: “I don’t need to sound as if I’m begging, as a result of I’ve decided that I cannot plead my case from my knees.” Of the quiet desperation that took maintain as soon as it was within the mail, she added: “I’m afraid that the surgeon will reply too quickly; I fear that he won’t reply in any respect; I concern that he’ll die or retire earlier than I can have the operation; I dread the surgical procedure; I dread extra a life with out it.”
However the holidays have been quick approaching, as have been her exams for a grasp’s diploma in English. Throughout vacation meals of turkey, dressing, pie, and wine with household and pals, she puzzled, Will I be alive subsequent Christmas? Will I be feminine?
Some say that the story of Stanley Biber in Trinidad started throughout a childhood practice journey from his native Des Moines, Iowa, to go to an uncle who lived on a Texas ranch. That’s the place, in accordance with his widow, Mary Lee, the dream of proudly owning a ranch and operating cattle might have caught fireplace within the younger man, a dream stoked and nurtured by Biber’s fondness for John Wayne films and the Hollywood model of Outdated West mythology.
Others recommend the story started extra immediately in Korea, throughout Biber’s time as a battlefield surgeon in a MASH unit. That’s the place he honed his expertise as a surgeon whereas making an attempt to save lots of troopers who’d been shot or who had stepped on a land mine, leaving their our bodies devastated by wounds to reproductive organs, bowels, and urinary tracts. That’s the place he developed a repute as tireless and decided, the place he supposedly cemented his legend by performing 37 consecutive surgical procedures earlier than passing out, and earned a commendation for finishing an operation even after shrapnel from an explosion exterior the surgical unit lodged in his butt, sending a stream of his personal blood down his leg as he labored.
In fact, there was a little bit of serendipity concerned as effectively. Biber was born Could 4, 1923, in Des Moines, the place his father owned a furnishings retailer and his mom stayed busy with native social causes. After briefly contemplating a profession as a live performance pianist, he graduated from highschool early and enrolled in a yeshiva in Chicago, desiring to develop into a rabbi. As occurred with so a lot of his era, World Warfare II interrupted his research.
The essential origin story of Biber’s life in Trinidad holds that he arrived in 1954 after serving as a civilian worker with the Workplace of Strategic Providers (OSS, the forerunner of the Central Intelligence Company) in Alaska and Canada’s Northwest Territories throughout World Warfare II. Biber, who was not but 20 on the time, didn’t discuss a lot about his work throughout that interval. “Simply say I used to be there,” he informed an interviewer in 1998. However Kelly Tucker, who in 1983 grew to become Biber’s monetary adviser, says Biber as soon as alluded vaguely to “blowing up Japanese radar bases.”
The precise particulars of Biber’s OSS service could also be misplaced to historical past. At greatest, they’re buried in inaccessible authorities information that even a Freedom of Info Act request couldn’t excavate. However it’s price noting that in June 1942, six months after the assault on Pearl Harbor, Japanese troops invaded two distant, sparsely inhabited Aleutian Islands named Attu and Kiska in what was then the American territory of Alaska. What adopted is a virtually forgotten chapter of the battle known as the Aleutian Islands marketing campaign. The Japanese army rapidly established bases there, about 1,200 miles west of the Alaska Peninsula, probably to watch any American makes an attempt to strike Japan from the Aleutians, or probably to dilute U.S. forces earlier than the deliberate Japanese strike on the extra strategic Halfway Island within the central Pacific. Both method, the islands represented the one U.S. soil captured by an enemy in the course of the battle, and due to that their recapture had nice symbolic worth.
After organising a naval blockade of the islands, the U.S. army landed 11,000 troops on Attu in Could 1943 to take it again. After a bloody two-day battle, greater than 2,000 Japanese troopers have been useless, as have been about 1,000 People. The Japanese occupiers quickly deserted Kiska, the place 35,000 American troopers landed unopposed in August 1943. Was Biber a part of that largely uncelebrated effort? It’s tough to say, although his cryptic feedback to Tucker increase that intriguing chance.
Biber excelled at plenty of issues throughout his postwar life, together with his premedical research to develop into a psychiatrist and his quest to develop into a member of the U.S. Olympic weightlifting workforce. He as soon as claimed to have missed that honor “by 20 kilos,” and even into his 80s was vulnerable to rolling his sleeves up over his biceps to indicate off his weapons. After graduating from medical college on the College of Iowa in 1948, he found a expertise and keenness for surgical procedure throughout his residency at an Military hospital within the Panama Canal Zone. He was additionally a gifted pianist, and he discovered that his dexterous fingers rapidly tailored to the high-quality motor expertise wanted throughout surgical procedure. He favored the problem of it and the chance to innovate as circumstances with the affected person modified. He excelled, and other people seen.
Biber ultimately discovered himself in Korea. “He was inspired by the federal government to both volunteer for 2 years or be drafted for 3,” Mary Lee Biber, his fifth and closing spouse, says. “So he volunteered and went to the DMZ as a MASH physician.” Because the unit’s chief surgeon, Biber as soon as informed an interviewer, he supervised such medical advances as vessel transplants and “acquired an amazing quantity of expertise.” He additionally grew to become an inadvertent hero, in accordance with two relations, after accompanying a helicopter pilot behind enemy traces to rescue wounded troopers. “He didn’t know he had crossed enemy traces!” says stepdaughter Kelly Mestas, whose mom, Ella Mae, was Biber’s fourth spouse. “He went and he picked them up. They have been capturing at him and the whole lot. And he introduced them again. However he stated, ‘Do you suppose I’m dumb? I wouldn’t have crossed enemy traces. I didn’t know!’”
After the battle, Biber was working on the Military’s Fort Carson close to Colorado Springs when a colleague requested him to hitch a five-member clinic deliberate by the United Mine Employees in Trinidad. He figured he’d assist get the clinic up and operating, then transfer on. However he didn’t. Whereas Las Animas County’s inhabitants peaked at almost 39,000 individuals in the course of the coal growth within the Twenties, it nonetheless had a post-boom inhabitants of about 26,000 residents by the Fifties. At that time, Biber was the one common surgeon on the town.
His focus was caring for the employees doing the damaging underground work on the Allen Mine, which opened in 1951 and was among the many most efficient within the state. He as soon as informed Ella Mae, to whom he was married for 23 years, that he knew he might apply drugs wherever on this planet. However he additionally informed her he by no means needed to go away Trinidad. “He was so devoted there,” she says. “He delivered so many infants, did all people’s surgical procedure, and all people trusted him tremendously. He cherished everybody in Trinidad. You don’t see docs decide to their sufferers anymore. He took care of them from start to dying, normally.” Mary Lee Biber, who labored as a nurse with Biber for 42 years earlier than changing into his fifth spouse, says she ended up marrying the person who’d been her physician since she was 15 years previous.
Biber as soon as described working 18-hour days, six days every week, throughout his early years in Trinidad. By many accounts, he did a little bit of the whole lot, from setting damaged bones, to repairing gunshot wounds, to resolving extra run-of-the-mill issues corresponding to hernias, hemorrhoids, and contaminated or burst appendixes. “He informed me he made $3,500 his first 12 months in Trinidad,” Mary Lee says. “He charged $3 for a home name and $2 for an workplace go to.”
He additionally started what in the end would develop into a really difficult household life—5 wives and 9 kids and stepchildren—throughout these years. He and his first spouse, Shirley, had 4 kids: Joann (who now goes by the identify Prabhu Nam Kaur Khalsa), Robert, Debbie, and Patricia. After the wedding resulted in divorce, Shirley determined to relocate with their youngsters to the Denver space, almost 200 miles north of Trinidad. The youngsters generally visited their father, and Biber apparently used his pilot’s license to go to them on weekends, however for a lot of their lives there remained a distance between Biber and people 4 kids.
Biber’s second marriage, to Sharon, was short-lived however produced a son, David, who now lives in a rural space close to Pueblo. The surgeon’s third marriage, to a nurse named Debbie, was transient as effectively, and produced no kids. The 23-year marriage to Ella Mae produced two kids, John and Terri, who shared Biber’s ranch dwelling with Ella Mae’s daughters from her earlier marriage, Pam and Kelly. Biber spent his closing years with longtime nurse Mary Lee Vigil, ultimately marrying her in 2005, lower than a 12 months earlier than his dying in January 2006, at age 82.
Biber’s skilled success carried on by all of it. The extra he labored, the extra he acquired to know the individuals in the neighborhood, and the extra helpful Biber felt. He touched many lives, in some ways, every single day. It’s exhausting to discover a native who’s not wanting to share a private story of the time Biber set their damaged bone, did minor surgical procedure throughout an workplace go to, or delivered them squalling into the world.
Lifelong Trinidad resident Dick Hamman recollects a day in 1960 when Biber saved his father’s life. The elder Hamman, a tough-it-out clerk on the Colorado and Southern Railway for almost 50 years, skilled extreme stomach ache at work and was despatched dwelling to recuperate after 4 days of struggling. The household physician requested a urine pattern, which Hamman’s mom collected in a sterilized jar. Younger Dick, then maybe eight or 9 years previous, rode the pattern to the physician’s Important Avenue workplace on his bicycle. The physician examined the pattern after which ordered Hamman’s father to the hospital, instantly.
After they arrived by automotive, Stanley Biber was ready and took the daddy into the working room, the place Biber found that his appendix had ruptured 4 days earlier. An infection of the stomach wall had already set in. “That’s a dying sentence,” Hamman’s son says. “He took my dad in, lower him open, and actually took his guts out, put them on the desk, washed all of them out, repaired the whole lot, put him again collectively, and sewed him up. And since then dad swore he was the very best ever. Earlier than that, he didn’t like Dr. Biber, however after that….” Hamman shakes his head as he recounts the story. “Everyone will let you know he was an excellent, good surgeon. And he was. He was excellent at it.”
The second that will change Biber’s life, the repute of his adopted hometown, and the lives of 1000’s of transgender sufferers “got here to him accidentally,” says stepdaughter Kelly. “It simply type of walked into his workplace at some point.”
His customer was a good friend, a social employee with whom Biber had consulted up to now on harelip and cleft palate instances from round Las Animas County. As Biber recounted in a 1998 interview, the red-haired lady lingered a second after the enterprise of the day was completed. Finally, she summoned the nerve to ask her vital query. Biber knew in regards to the extensively reported case wherein Christine Jorgensen had been surgically remodeled. However on the time, the time period transsexual or transgender was hardly a part of the cultural vocabulary.
After his customer defined that she was among the many first sufferers to be handled with feminine hormones by pioneering gender researcher Dr. Harry Benjamin, Biber started educating himself the identical afternoon—apparently after he’d tentatively agreed to do the operation. He realized that Benjamin was a German-born protégé of Magnus Hirschfeld, who Susan Stryker, writer of the 2008 e-book Transgender Historical past, says first superior the speculation of “sexual intermediaries”—the notion that every particular person represents a singular mixture of intercourse traits, secondary sex-linked traits, erotic preferences, psychological inclinations, and culturally acquired habits and practices.
Benjamin moved to america in 1913, and by the Fifties had established himself because the main American authority on transgender points. It could be one other decade earlier than Benjamin’s “requirements of care” would develop into the accepted protocol for treating transgender sufferers, however Biber’s customer apparently already was adhering to primary tenets of these requirements. She was taking hormones, had handed Benjamin’s psychological standards for the surgical procedure, and already had lived for a full 12 months as a girl.
On the time, the Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore was the American heart of what then was known as intercourse change surgical procedure. Biber known as Dr. John Hoopes, a plastic surgeon at Johns Hopkins who on the time had achieved about 13 such operations, seven of which have been what Biber described as “easy penectomies,” just like the operation achieved on Jorgensen. Hoopes ultimately despatched Biber a set of rudimentary hand-drawn diagrams exhibiting the fundamental approach for deconstructing a person’s genitalia and reconstructing it right into a type of artisanal vagina.
Biber regarded over the drawings and known as the social employee again. “Nicely, I’ve by no means achieved one, however if you wish to do it, I feel we will do it.” She agreed, and Biber for the primary time carried out a process referred to as the penile-scrotal flap, a way he later described as “horrible trying.” However he additionally stated it appeared to work moderately effectively.
Within the early Nineteen Seventies, transgender individuals searching for surgical reduction didn’t have many choices. Issues have been altering, for positive. Because of the social and sexual upheavals of the Nineteen Sixties, ladies carrying pants in public not triggered a fuss, and males whose hair spilled over their collars have been extra the norm than the exception. Gender-bending entertainers such because the New York Dolls and David Bowie have been discovering their methods into the American mainstream. Historian Susan Stryker describes the dawning of a momentarily cool “transgender aesthetic” again then that signaled a altering relationship between look and organic intercourse, even when the extra entrenched types of gender discrimination and sexism remained firmly in place.
For transgender women and men, Stanley Biber’s nascent apply in Trinidad was a revelation. Right here was a talented surgeon at an actual hospital who supplied them assist, dignity, and hope—all with a dose of maximum confidence, and with out judgment. On the time, that mixture was sufficient to coax reluctant and generally determined individuals to Trinidad from 1000’s of miles away.
Simply three weeks after she’d first reached out to the famend surgeon, Griggs discovered a letter in her mailbox postmarked Trinidad, Colorado, from the workplaces of Dr. Stanley Biber. She braced herself.
Biber’s response was, she says, “a nice shock.” His letter merely described the obtainable providers—genital surgical procedure, breast implants, a tracheal shave to scale back the Adam’s apple, rhinoplasty—and their corresponding prices. It described the necessity for 2 psychiatric evaluations recommending her for surgical procedure, and the necessity to write and ahead to Biber a social historical past of herself. Additionally, Griggs was informed that she will need to have been dwelling full-time as a girl for no less than one 12 months earlier than she could be thought of. She’d already been dwelling overtly as a girl for 17.
The fee breakdown, payable in full on the time of the surgical procedure, could be as follows: Biber’s surgical charge, $4,850; hospital price, $5,435; anesthesiologist charge, $925. Breast implants weren’t included, however have been obtainable for an additional price. Insurance coverage wouldn’t cowl the surgical procedure, the letter famous, however Biber promised to refund acceptable charges if she made a profitable declare in opposition to her medical insurer. It ended: “We will probably be glad to assist in the event you can meet our necessities.”
Once more, Griggs started to cry.
By January 21, 1991, lower than two months after she first wrote to Biber, Griggs was able to ship one other letter that included the requested “transient social historical past.” It was 10 pages lengthy, single-spaced, starting along with her start in Millington, Tennessee, 37 years earlier; her youth because the youngster of an Air Drive and California Nationwide Guard “lifer”; her main and secondary schooling in Southern California; her personal 12 months and a half as an info specialist within the Air Drive; her honorable discharge from the army after revealing her gender-identity state of affairs; her schooling and work historical past; and her usually unsatisfying sexual historical past with each female and male lovers. On the time, she wrote, she was concerned in a four-year relationship with a girl named Carolyn, “the primary relationship I’ve ever dared hope will probably be everlasting.”
“I’ve requested myself why, if I’m so pleased, do I hunt down a surgeon as I strategy center age; I can provide you with solely partial solutions,” she defined to Biber. “I do know that if surgical procedure have been inconceivable to realize, I might survive with out it, bearing the discomfort of my current bodily situation in a lot the identical method (I feel) I’d bear up if I have been paralyzed from the waist down and needed to spend my life in a wheelchair. It could be a distressing state of affairs, it could current some grave obstacles, it could be miserable, however it could not cease me from reaching out to work, research, be taught, and simply hold shifting by life.”
She additionally enclosed {a photograph} and famous in closing that the associated fee could be manageable. “I could flinch once I withdraw the funds from my financial savings, however I can afford your charges.” About three months later, on April 27, Griggs acquired the reply that each thrilled and frightened her. Biber accepted her as a “surgical candidate” and enclosed a four-page info packet known as “The Trinidad Expertise: Info About Your Hospital Keep (Male to Feminine Process).” However the resolution was not but closing, Biber defined: “Although you may have been accepted as a candidate, please keep in mind that I’ll make the ultimate resolution in my workplace the day previous to your scheduled surgical procedure.”
Nonetheless, Griggs allowed herself some hope. Fifteen years after her first makes an attempt to discover a surgeon, she discovered herself reassured by this voice from the Colorado wilderness, by Biber’s professionalism and confidence, by the truth that, as she wrote, “medical care is being supplied virtually routinely to a subdued transsexual who had given up on the lookout for a treatment, resolving as an alternative to simply accept the ache of existence—bodily, legally, psychologically—in a type of sexual limbo.”
For the primary time in what appeared like without end, Claudine Griggs imagined the life she felt born to stay.
This text is tailored from Going to Trinidad: A Doctor, a Colorado Town, and Stories from an Unlikely Gender Crossroads, which will probably be printed by Bower Home Books on April 15; Tantor Media will launch Going to Trinidad as an audio e-book on that very same day.
Martin J. Smith is the writer of 5 novels and 5 nonfiction books, and is a frequent 5280 contributor. E-mail him at letters@5280.com.
